Federal Appeals Court Rules Transportation Department Wrongly Withheld $73.5 Million in New York Highway Funds; Old CDL Rule Does Not Apply Retroactively

A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ruled on November 13 that the federal government acted unlawfully in withholding nearly $74 million in highway funds from New York State, vacating the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration's decision. The court found the agency had penalized New York in a manner that was arbitrary, capricious or contrary to law. The dispute stemmed from a federal audit last year that found about 32,600 non-domiciled commercial driver's licenses issued by New York remained valid for too long, up to eight years, far beyond the holders' lawful-status documents. In April the agency issued a final determination that New York was substantially noncompliant and withheld 4 percent of its fiscal 2027 federal highway funds, totaling $73,502,543. The court noted that the requirement linking license validity to lawful-status documents did not exist in the regulations in effect when the licenses were issued, a point the agency itself conceded in litigation. Judge Alison Nathan wrote that the agency could have adopted a new rule through rulemaking but could not withhold funds based on a requirement that did not exist at the time. The new federal rule took effect only on March 16, 2026, and does not apply retroactively. Governor Kathy Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James welcomed the ruling in a joint statement, calling it a victory for millions of New Yorkers who rely on safe roads. The Transportation Department responded that continuing to enforce the new rule is the way to protect public safety. The case number is 26-1097.
Published by GSM · USA (original Chinese edition)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons,作者 Kidfly182,CC BY 4.0;图中是位于曼哈顿的瑟古德·马歇尔联邦法院大楼,第二巡回上诉法院所在地;资料照片,非本事件实拍

